Should I Repair or Replace My Garage Doors?

You’re pulling into your driveway after a long day, and then it happens – the dreaded garage door malfunction. You ask, ‘Should I get garage door replacement or repair?’

It’s essential to consider factors such as the age of your garage door, the extent of damage, the costs involved, and future maintenance requirements.

As an informed homeowner, this decision should be based on thorough knowledge and understanding. In this article, we’ll guide you through when it’s best to repair your existing setup versus when you should consider installing a brand-new system.

When to Repair Your Garage Door


If you’re noticing that your garage door springs are broken, the rollers have derailed, or there’s a damaged panel, it might be time to consider a repair.

You Have Broken Springs

When your garage door springs give up the ghost, it’s a hassle, but don’t rush to replace the whole system. This part is usually repairable, and doing so can save you quite a bit of money.

Consider these points:

  • Garage door springs are under high tension and can be dangerous if mishandled. Always hire a professional to do this job.
  • Springs have a finite lifespan and typically need replacing every 7-9 years, depending on usage.
  • Replacing broken springs is generally less expensive than installing a new garage door system.
  • Regular maintenance helps prolong spring life – lubricate them annually and check for signs of wear or damage.

Your Garage Door Rollers Are Off Track

Navigating your driveway becomes a nightmare as you’re greeted by the grating sound of off-track rollers, making every entrance and exit an ordeal. The problem isn’t just annoying; it can also pose a risk to safety and property.

When your garage door rollers are off track, they won’t glide smoothly along the rails. This might cause your door to jam or even fall suddenly. Not only does this put your car at risk of damage, but it could also harm you or anyone nearby.

In such cases, immediate repair is essential. However, if this issue recurs frequently or other parts of the door are worn out, too, replacement may be more cost-effective in the long run. Always consult a professional garage expert before making any decisions about your garage doors’ health and longevity.

You Have a Damaged Door Panel

There’s no worse feeling than coming home to a damaged door panel. The unsightly dents and scratches mar the overall aesthetic of your home. It can be a significant deterrent to your home’s curb appeal and even affect its value.

However, don’t let this ruin your day or blow up your budget. If only one or two panels are damaged, it might be more cost-effective to simply repair them rather than replace the entire garage door. A garage door specialist can easily remove the damaged panels and install new ones that match your existing door.

You Are Having Garage Door Opener Issues

Experiencing issues with your door opener can certainly test your patience, often leaving you unable to access or secure your garage as needed. The problem could be caused by various factors ranging from simple battery failure to worn-out gears or motors.

Firstly, check whether the remote and wall unit batteries are functioning well. If that doesn’t solve the issue, it might be due to a misaligned photo-eye sensor or a broken chain drive mechanism. It’s also possible for the entire unit to wear out over time.

The Door Is Heavy to Open

If you’re finding it a bit of a workout to lift your door, it’s likely because the garage door torsion springs are worn out or broken. These crucial components counterbalance the weight of your garage door, making it fairly effortless for you to open and close. When these springs fail, not only does your door become heavy, but it is also dangerous if it slams shut unexpectedly.

Before deciding on repair or replacement, consider your garage door’s age and overall condition. Repairing might be cost-effective if they’re relatively new with no other issues. However, if they’re old or showing signs of wear and tear in other areas, too, replacing them might be more prudent.

When to Replace Your Garage Door

If your garage door has seen more than 15 years of service, is showing signs of severe damage, or constantly requires repairs, it might be time to consider a replacement.

Your Garage Door Is Older than 15 Years

Got a garage door that’s more than 15 years old? It might be time to consider replacing it. While regular maintenance can extend its lifespan, an older door could still present problems.

1. Safety risks: Old garage doors may not have the latest safety features like auto-reverse or motion sensor technology.

2. Frequent repairs: You’re likely dealing with constant breakdowns and expensive repair bills.

3. Energy inefficiency: Older doors often lack proper insulation, leading to higher energy costs.

4. Outdated appearance: Aging garage doors can detract from your home’s curb appeal.

There Is Severe Damage

Severe damage to your portal can be a major concern, posing risks not only to your vehicle but also potentially threatening your family’s safety. Significant impairment might make it difficult for the door to function properly, whether due to a natural disaster or an unfortunate accident.

Consider factors like whether the door still opens and closes smoothly, if there are visible cracks or splits in garage door panels that could compromise its structural integrity, or if it’s become unbalanced, causing undue stress on the motor and other mechanisms. If these issues persist despite repair attempts, replacement may be more cost-effective and safer in the long run.

You Want an Upgrade for Curb Appeal

Perhaps you’re ready to spruce up your home’s exterior, and a fresh new portal is just what you’re looking for. Upgrading your garage doors can be an excellent move offering more than an aesthetic boost.

1. Increase Home Value: New doors can significantly increase the value of your home in case you decide to sell.

2. Improved Energy Efficiency: Modern garage doors are often better insulated, reducing energy consumption.

3. Enhanced Security Features: Updated models often have improved security features that provide greater protection against break-ins.

4. Reduced Maintenance: Newer models usually require less maintenance, saving you time and money in the long run.

Your Garage Door Needs Constant Repairs

If you’re constantly calling in the experts for fixes, it might be a sign that your old portal is on its last legs. Frequent breakdowns are inconvenient and can lead to expensive repair costs over time.

When your garage door demands consistent attention, it’s often more cost-effective to replace it entirely rather than continually patching up problems. A new door will improve reliability and functionality, saving you from frustrating disruptions and unexpected expenses. It can also boost energy efficiency and security, presenting additional long-term value.

Call the Experts at Hung Rite Garage Door for Repairs and Replacements


Trust the garage door experts at Hung Rite Garage Door for all your garage door needs. Our experienced garage door repair technicians can easily fix broken doors or upgrade them. We have extensive experience replacing and repairing residential and commercial garage doors. Unlike other garage door installation companies, we don’t subcontract our services and never push unnecessary products. Our priority is always our customers, and we take pride in our honesty and reputation. Save time and hassle by letting our expert technicians quickly identify and fix any issues with your garage door. Instead of searching online for prices on different parts, simply give us a call. We are confident in fulfilling all your garage door repair needs.

Garage door services we provide:

  • Residential and Commercial Garage Repair
  • Garage Door Installation
  • Garage Door Repair Services
  • Garage Door Opener Repair
  • Broken Garage Spring Repair
  • And More

Visit our About Us page for more information about our garage door company.